14 INVESTMENT IN ASSOCIATES AND JOINT VENTURES     
     (Loss)/income from
associates and joint ventures 
Carrying value
of the investment 
       2020 
Rm 
2019 
Rm 
2020 
Rm 
2019 
Rm 
  Associates  47  (15) 745  693 
  Joint ventures  (95) 246  1 403  1 560 
  Total per income statement/statement of financial position  (48) 231  2 148  2 253 

 

Impairment of investments arises when the recoverable amount of the Investment is less than the carrying value. The recoverable amount is determined as the greater of the fair value less costs to sell or the value in use. For the purposes of assessing the above Investments for impairment, the recoverable amount was based on the fair value less costs to sell method.

With the outbreak of the COVID-19 global pandemic, the resulting global economic downturn and the credit rating downgrade of South Africa to sub-investment grade all investments in associates and joint ventures were assessed for impairment at 30 September 2020 which resulted in the below mentioned impairments.


  Impairments recognised in the year  Geographical
location 
Reportable
segment 
2020 
Rm 
2019 
Rm 
  BHBW South Africa (Pty) Limited  South Africa  Equipment and
Handling 
187    
  BHBW Zambia Limited  Zambia  Equipment and
Handling 
16 
  Barloworld Maponya (Pty) Limited*  South Africa  Automotive  16 
  Total        210  25 

  * The impairment of loan in Barloworld Maponya (Pty) Ltd in the current year is recognised in operating expenses.

     Bartrac
Equipment
Limited 
BHBW
South Africa
(Pty) Limited 
NMI Durban
South
Motors (Pty)
Ltd* 
  Pre-tax nominal discount rate  19.7%  17.4%  15.3% 
  Terminal growth rate  1.9%  4.7%  4.7% 

  * It should be noted that the investment in NMI Durban South Motors (Pty) Ltd was impaired by R124 million at 31 March 2020 but has subsequently been reversed after it was concluded that since the economy transitioned to level 3 lockdown with dealerships allowed to resume operations, an improvement in vehicle sales was experienced. As a result of the extensive planning prior to the relaxation of restrictions, supported by our existing infrastructure the dealership was in a position to commence trading as soon as restrictions were eased. This readiness, coupled with the sufficient availability of vehicles, enabled successfully trade since the restrictions have tapered off.

 

Reasons for impairment are as follows:

BHBW South Africa (Pty) Ltd
Projections indicate the Company will continue to make losses through 2020 and 2021 impacted by the COVID-19 crisis and the related economic downturn. The impairment recognised is a reflection of projected cash flows in the current market environment. The discount rate increased in the period under review, further impacting on the valuation.

The sensitivity of management's assumptions as applied in the valuation is demonstrated below. Specifically, the sensitivity analysis indicates the point at which the headroom over the carrying value is reduced to zero (break even). Each sensitivity has been performed independently and not cumulatively across all assumptions.

As at 30 September 2020, management have performed sufficient sensitivity analysis to conclude that a reasonably possible change in key assumptions would not cause the carrying amount of the Group's individual CGUs to exceed their recoverable amount (fair value less costs to sell) (other than for those investments that were impaired in the year).


  The pre-tax nominal discount rates (discount rate) breakeven sensitivity  BHBW 
South Africa 
(Pty) Limited 
  Discount rate base case  17.4% 
  Discount rate breakeven level^  18.3% 

  * Level of discount rate at which Headroom is R0.

  Long-term growth breakeven sensitivity  BHBW 
South Africa 
(Pty) Limited 
  Base case long-term growth rate  4.7% 
  Long-term growth rate breakeven level*  3.3% 

  * Long-term growth rate can drop to below 0% before investment is fully impaired.

 

DETAILS OF MATERIAL JOINT VENTURES

Details of material joint ventures at the end of the reporting period are as follows:

  Name of joint venture  Principal
activity 
Place of
incorporation 
Proportion of ownership interest
and voting rights held by the
Group 
           2020  2019 
  Bartrac Equipment Limited  Caterpillar dealer  Mauritius  50%  50% 

 

The joint venture operates in Mauritius and the DRC.

Summarised financial information in respect of the Group's material joint venture is set out below, the summarised financial information represents amounts shown in the joint venture's financial statements prepared in accordance with IFRS.

  Bartrac Equipment Limited  2020 
Rm 
2019 
Rm 
  Statement of financial position       
  Cash and cash equivalents  401  79 
  Total current assets (excluding cash and cash equivalents) 1 621  2 222 
  Non-current assets  1 389  1 112 
  Total current liabilities  506  676 
  Total non-current liabilities  205  205 
  Net asset value  2 700  2 532 
  Barloworld share of net asset value  1 350  1 266 
  Income statement       
  Revenue  2 966  4 506 
  Depreciation and amortisation  (103) (122)
  Interest income     40 
  Interest expense  (24)   
  Income tax expense  (83) 68 
  (Loss)/net profit after tax  (82) 536 

  Reconciliation of the carrying amount of the interest in Bartrac recognised in the consolidated financial statements  2020 
Rm 
2019 
Rm 
  Original cost  38  38 
  Equity accounted earnings to date  1 550  1 591 
  Dividends  (719) (719)
  Foreign Currency Translation  481  356 
  Carrying amount of the Group's interest in Bartrac Equipment Limited  1 350  1 266 

  Name of Joint Venture  Principal activity  Place of incorporation  Proportion of ownership interest
and voting rights held by the
Group 
           2020  2019 
  BHBW South Africa (Proprietary) Limited  Supply of Agricultural and Materials Handling goods and services South Africa  50%  50% 

 

Summarised financial information in respect of the Group's material joint venture is set out below, the summarised financial information
represents amounts shown in the joint venture's financial statements prepared in accordance with IFRS.


  BHBW South Africa (Proprietary) Limited  2020 
Rm 
2019 
Rm 
  Statement of financial position       
  Total current assets  639  948 
  Non-current assets  428  300 
  Current financial liabilities (excluding trade and other payables and provisions) 41  388 
  Total current liabilities  603  654 
  Total non-current liabilities     13 
  Net asset value  464  581 
  Barloworld share of net asset value  232  290 
  Income statement       
  Revenue  1 193  1 256 
  Depreciation and amortisation  69  16 
  Interest expense  37  28 
  Income tax expense  (2) (10)
  Net loss after tax  (116) (32)

  Reconciliation of the carrying amount of the interest in BHBW South Africa (Proprietary)
Limited recognised in the consolidated financial statements 
2020 
Rm 
2019 
Rm 
  Original cost  301  301 
  Equity accounted (loss)/earnings to date  (69) (11)
  Impairment recognised  (187)   
  Carrying amount of the group's interest in BHBW South Africa (Proprietary) Limited  45  290 

  Aggregate information of other joint ventures that are not individually material:  2020 
Rm 
2019 
Rm 
  Group's share of loss  (6)

  Reconciliation of income statement/statement of financial position    (Loss)/income
from joint venture 
Carrying value
of the investment 
2020 
Rm 
2019 
Rm 
2020 
Rm 
2019 
Rm 
    
  Bartrac Equipment Limited and BHBW South Africa (Proprietary) Limited  (99) 252  1 395  1 556 
  Aggregate loss/carrying value of non-material joint ventures  (6)
  Total income and carrying value of joint ventures  (95) 246  1 403  1 560 

  DETAILS OF MATERIAL ASSOCIATES
   Name of associates  Principal
activity 
Place
of incorporation 
Proportion
of ownership
interest and
voting rights
held by the
group 
2020 
  2019 
  NMI Durban South Motors (Pty) Ltd  Sale and servicing of motor
vehicles and sale of parts 
South Africa  50%  50% 

 

Summarised financial information in respect of the group's material associates is set out below, the summarised financial information represents amounts shown in the associate's financial statements prepared in accordance with IFRS.

The group accounts for NMI Durban South Motors (Pty Ltd using the equity accounting method as Barloworld has the power to participants in the financial and operating policy decision of the investee but in control or joint control of these policies.

Although Barloworld has 50% interest, joint control does not exist because the remaining 50% investment in NMI Durban South Motors (Pty) Ltd is held by two parties.


  NMI Durban South Motors (Pty) Ltd  2020 
Rm 
2019 
Rm 
  Statement of financial position       
  Cash and cash equivalents  209  126 
  Total current assets (excluding cash and cash equivalents) 780  978 
  Non-current assets  1 400  1 389 
  Current financial liabilities (excluding trade and other payables and provisions) 31 
  Total current liabilities  873  979 
  Non-current financial liabilities (excluding trade and other payables and provisions) 59  143 
  Total non-current liabilities  206  301 
  Net asset value*  1 310  1 213 
  Barloworld share of net asset value excluding goodwill  656  607 
  Goodwill  10  10 
  Barloworld share of net asset value including goodwill  666  617 
  Income statement       
  Revenue  3 644  320 
  Depreciation and amortisation  (43)
  Interest income 
  Income tax expense or income  (11)
  Net profit after tax  110 

  * The prior year total current assets was adjusted by R126 million due to a duplication of the cash and cash equivalents and the net asset value was adjusted by R195 million for the at acquisition fair value adjustments.

  Reconciliation of the carrying amount of the interest in NMI Durban South Motors (Pty) Ltd
recognised in the consolidated financial statements 
2020 
Rm 
2019 
Rm 
  Original cost  451  451 
  Goodwill  212  212 
  Equity accounted earnings to date  56 
  Adoption on 1 October 2019 upon transition to IFRS 16 Standard^  (3)   
  Dividends  (50) (50)
  Carrying amount of the group's interest in NMI Durban South Motors (Pty) Ltd  666  617 

  * Refer to note 37 related to changes in accounting policies

  Aggregate information of other associate that are not individually material:  2020 
Rm 
2019 
Rm 
  Group's share of loss  (5) (19)

  Reconciliation of income statement/
statement of financial position 
Income/(loss) from associate  Carrying value of the investment 
       2020 
Rm 
2019 
Rm 
2020 
Rm 
2019 
Rm 
  NMI Durban South Motors (Pty) Ltd  55  666  617 
  Aggregate (loss)/carrying value of other non-material associates#  (8) (19) 79  76 
  Total (loss)/income and carrying value of associates  47  (15) 745  693 

  # Included in the carrying value of associates, that are not individually material, is Menlyn Main Towers (Pty) Ltd, in which Barloworld has a 50% shareholding , Irene Khaya Property Investment (Pty) Ltd, in which Barloworld also has a 50% shareholding and Optron (Pty) Ltd in which Barloworld has a 20% shareholding. These entities are not jointly controlled and as such are classified as associates.

  All of the associates and joint ventures are incorporated and operational in South Africa, except:

  Name of the Associate/Joint Ventures  Principal Activity  Place of incorporation  Year-end 
  Barzem Enterprises (Pty) Limited  Caterpillar dealer  Zimbabwe  31 August* 
  Bartrac Equipment Limited  Caterpillar dealer  Mauritius  31 December* 
  Africa United Equipment  Liaison Office  Hong Kong  31 December* 

  * The different year ends of the associates and joint ventures listed above have been agreed to based on the tax year ends of the jurisdictions in which these businesses operate and/or to coincide with our partners' financial year ends and do not have a material impact on the results.
 

There are no restrictions on the ability of the group's joint ventures and associates to transfer funds to the Group in the form of cash dividends or to repay loans or advances owing to the Group.

The Group has no commitments arising from its involvement with joint ventures and associates.

Financial liabilities arising from the issuance of guarantees over obligations of the joint ventures and associates are disclosed in credit risk note 34.2.d. The Group considers the probability of loss arising from these guarantees as remote as the financial position of these investments is considered sufficient to repay debts as and when they are due and payable.